Thursday, March 24, 2011

The best and worst telecoms operators in SA

A basic analysis of feedback on HelloPeter reveals which telecoms providers attract the most compliments and complaints from subscribers - Rudolph Muller, MyBroadband.


HelloPeter has become South Africa’s most popular destination for consumers wanting to lodge complaints about companies from which they received poor service.

According to the HelloPeter website 42,895 complaints were lodged by South African consumers over the last 90 days, bearing testimony to the popularity of the consumer website.

Unsurprisingly complaints significantly outnumber compliments, but to try to establish an objective measure of the service levels of a company HelloPeter provides visitors with league tables which include a compliments/complaints ratio.

This ratio indicates which percentage of feedback received is positive, giving a loose indication of the service levels of a company.

The following table provides an overview of the compliments/complaints ratio of South Africa’s
telecoms operators over the last twelve months.

Compliments/Compliments Ratio (larger is better)

Complaints Compliments Compliments/Complaints Ratio (%)
Virgin Mobile 2341 318 13.6
Neotel 583 79 13.6
Vodacom 7494 1002 13.4
Cell C 5960 667 11.2
MTN 7668 756 9.9
Telkom 1733 161 9.3
iBurst 487 19 3.9

While a compliments/complaints ratio may be a fair way to measure service levels, a better way may be to measure the number of complaints per 1,000 customers received over the last twelve months. The following table does exactly that for the country’s largest telecoms companies.

Since HelloPeter is essentially a website where people complain about poor service, it makes sense to see how many complaints a certain company received when compared to their customer base.

It should be noted that the subscriber numbers listed below is based on the last publicly available figures.

Complaints per 1000 customers (lower is better)

Complaints Customers Complaints/1000 Customers
Vodacom 7494 25,300,000 0.30
Telkom 1733 4,300,000 0.40
MTN 7668 18,800,000 0.41
Cell C 5960 7,000,000 0.85
iBurst 487 70,000 6.96
Virgin Mobile 2341 300,000 7.80
Neotel 583 50,000 11.66

No comments:

Post a Comment